@startuml
!define RECTANGLE(x, y, w, h) rectangle "x" as x at (y, h)
!define ARROW(from, to, label) from -> to : label

skinparam backgroundColor #FFFFFF
skinparam defaultFontSize 14
skinparam rectangle {
  BorderColor #333333
  BackgroundColor #F0F0F0
}

title Stand-Alone Artifact Editor - MVP vs Over-Engineered Approaches

rectangle "Add diagram to discussion comment" as goal #LightBlue
rectangle "MVP Path (2-4 weeks)" as mvp_path #LightGreen
rectangle "Complex Path (6-9 months)" as complex_path #LightCoral

rectangle "1. Text editor for PlantUML\n2. Save contract (ARTIFACT_SAVED)\n3. Use existing discussion-diagram-editor SmartTool\n4. Simple preview on save" as mvp_details #LightGreen

rectangle "1. Graphical canvas with drag-drop\n2. Bidirectional text-canvas sync\n3. Voice command integration\n4. Live preview with timer\n5. Multiple format support\n6. Custom GUI framework" as complex_details #LightCoral

rectangle "MVP Outcome" as mvp_outcome #LightGreen
rectangle "Complex Outcome" as complex_outcome #LightCoral

rectangle "Working integration\nUsers can add diagrams\nImmediate value\nIterate based on feedback" as mvp_outcome_details #LightGreen

rectangle "Feature-rich editor\nMonths of development\nHigh risk of scope creep\nDelayed user value" as complex_outcome_details #LightCoral

goal --> mvp_path : "Simplest path"
goal --> complex_path : "Ambitious vision"

mvp_path --> mvp_details
complex_path --> complex_details

mvp_details --> mvp_outcome : "Ship in weeks"
complex_details --> complex_outcome : "Ship in months"

mvp_outcome --> mvp_outcome_details
complex_outcome --> complex_outcome_details

rectangle "GUI Framework Options" as gui_options #LightYellow {
  rectangle "PyQt6/PySide6\nMature, rich widgets\nGood for drawing\nSteep learning curve" as pyqt
  rectangle "Dear PyGui\nUsed by parent project\nLimited drawing capabilities\nFast to implement" as dearpygui  
  rectangle "Web-based (Electron)\nMost flexible\nHeavy dependencies\nCross-platform" as web
  rectangle "TUI (urwid)\nSimplest\nNo graphical canvas\nTerminal-only" as tui
}

note right of mvp_path
  **Recommended MVP Stack:**
  - Text editor: urwid TUI
  - AI: discussion-diagram-editor SmartTool
  - Preview: Render on save
  - Contract: ARTIFACT_SAVED
end note

note right of complex_path
  **Complexity Drivers:**
  - Graphical canvas implementation
  - Bidirectional sync logic
  - Voice command pipeline
  - Live preview architecture
  - Multiple format renderers
end note

@enduml
@startuml
!define RECTANGLE(x, y, w, h) rectangle "x" as x at (y, h)
!define ARROW(from, to, label) from -> to : label

skinparam backgroundColor #FFFFFF
skinparam defaultFontSize 14
skinparam rectangle {
  BorderColor #333333
  BackgroundColor #F0F0F0
}

title Stand-Alone Artifact Editor - MVP vs Over-Engineered Approaches

rectangle "User Goal" as goal #LightBlue
rectangle "MVP Path (2-4 weeks)" as mvp_path #LightGreen
rectangle "Complex Path (6-9 months)" as complex_path #LightCoral

goal : "Add diagram to discussion comment"

mvp_path : "1. Text editor for PlantUML\n2. Save contract (ARTIFACT_SAVED)\n3. Use existing discussion-diagram-editor SmartTool\n4. Simple preview on save"

complex_path : "1. Graphical canvas with drag-drop\n2. Bidirectional text-canvas sync\n3. Voice command integration\n4. Live preview with timer\n5. Multiple format support\n6. Custom GUI framework"

rectangle "MVP Outcome" as mvp_outcome #LightGreen
rectangle "Complex Outcome" as complex_outcome #LightCoral

mvp_outcome : "Working integration\nUsers can add diagrams\nImmediate value\nIterate based on feedback"

complex_outcome : "Feature-rich editor\nMonths of development\nHigh risk of scope creep\nDelayed user value"

goal --> mvp_path : "Simplest path"
goal --> complex_path : "Ambitious vision"

mvp_path --> mvp_outcome : "Ship in weeks"
complex_path --> complex_outcome : "Ship in months"

rectangle "GUI Framework Options" as gui_options #LightYellow {
  rectangle "PyQt6/PySide6" as pyqt
  rectangle "Dear PyGui" as dearpygui  
  rectangle "Web-based (Electron)" as web
  rectangle "TUI (urwid)" as tui
}

pyqt : "Mature, rich widgets\nGood for drawing\nSteep learning curve"
dearpygui : "Used by parent project\nLimited drawing capabilities\nFast to implement"
web : "Most flexible\nHeavy dependencies\nCross-platform"
tui : "Simplest\nNo graphical canvas\nTerminal-only"

note right of mvp_path
  **Recommended MVP Stack:**
  - Text editor: urwid TUI
  - AI: discussion-diagram-editor SmartTool
  - Preview: Render on save
  - Contract: ARTIFACT_SAVED
end note

note right of complex_path
  **Complexity Drivers:**
  - Graphical canvas implementation
  - Bidirectional sync logic
  - Voice command pipeline
  - Live preview architecture
  - Multiple format renderers
end note

@enduml