Add missing participant SmartTools

Added 7 additional AI participants:
- discussion-backend: Backend/API perspective
- discussion-designer: Visual/UX design perspective
- discussion-devops: Infrastructure/deployment perspective
- discussion-frontend: Frontend/UI perspective
- discussion-performance: Performance/optimization perspective
- discussion-qa: Testing/quality perspective
- discussion-ux: User experience perspective

These are now bundled with the project and will be installed
automatically when building the Docker container.

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

smarttools/discussion-backend/config.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,141 @@
+name: discussion-backend
+description: Backend development specialist participant for discussions
+category: Discussion
+meta:
+  display_name: AI-Backend
+  alias: backend
+  type: voting
+  expertise:
+  - API design
+  - Database design
+  - Server architecture
+  - Authentication/Authorization
+  - Data modeling
+  - Microservices
+  - Message queues
+  concerns:
+  - Is the API design RESTful/consistent?
+  - What's the data model?
+  - How do we handle transactions?
+  - Is authentication properly implemented?
+  voice: en-AU-Neural2-B
+  provider: codex
+  color:
+  - 100
+  - 200
+  - 100
+arguments:
+- flag: --callout
+  variable: callout
+  default: ''
+  description: Specific question or @mention context
+- flag: --templates-dir
+  variable: templates_dir
+  default: templates
+  description: Path to templates directory
+- flag: --diagrams-dir
+  variable: diagrams_dir
+  default: diagrams
+  description: Path to save diagrams
+- flag: --log-file
+  variable: log_file
+  default: ''
+  description: Path to log file for progress updates
+steps:
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\nphase_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Phase:\\s*(\\w+)\\\
+    s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\ntemplate_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Template:\\\
+    s*(\\w+)\\s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\n\ncurrent_phase = phase_match.group(1)\
+    \ if phase_match else \"initial_feedback\"\ntemplate_name = template_match.group(1)\
+    \ if template_match else \"feature\"\n\ntemplate_path = os.path.join(templates_dir,\
+    \ template_name + \".yaml\")\nphase_goal = \"Provide backend feedback\"\nphase_instructions\
+    \ = \"Review the proposal for backend implementation concerns.\"\n\nif os.path.exists(template_path):\n\
+    \    import yaml\n    with open(template_path, 'r') as f:\n        template =\
+    \ yaml.safe_load(f)\n    phases = template.get(\"phases\", {})\n    phase_info\
+    \ = phases.get(current_phase, {})\n    phase_goal = phase_info.get(\"goal\", phase_goal)\n\
+    \    phase_instructions = phase_info.get(\"instructions\", phase_instructions)\n\
+    \nphase_context = \"Current Phase: \" + current_phase + \"\\n\"\nphase_context\
+    \ += \"Phase Goal: \" + phase_goal + \"\\n\"\nphase_context += \"Phase Instructions:\\\
+    n\" + phase_instructions\n"
+  output_var: phase_context, current_phase
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\ntitle_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Title:\\s*(.+?)\\\
+    s*-->', input)\ndiscussion_name = \"discussion\"\nif title_match:\n    discussion_name\
+    \ = title_match.group(1).strip().lower()\n    discussion_name = re.sub(r'[^a-z0-9]+',\
+    \ '-', discussion_name)\n\nos.makedirs(diagrams_dir, exist_ok=True)\n\nexisting\
+    \ = []\nif os.path.exists(diagrams_dir):\n    for f in os.listdir(diagrams_dir):\n\
+    \        if f.startswith(discussion_name):\n            existing.append(f)\n\n\
+    next_num = len(existing) + 1\ndiagram_path = diagrams_dir + \"/\" + discussion_name\
+    \ + \"_backend_\" + str(next_num) + \".puml\"\n"
+  output_var: diagram_path
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nfor msg in [f\"Phase: {current_phase}\", \"Calling AI provider...\"\
+    ]:\n    line = f\"[{timestamp}] [backend] {msg}\"\n    print(line, file=sys.stderr)\n\
+    \    sys.stderr.flush()\n    if log_file:\n        with open(log_file, 'a') as\
+    \ f:\n            f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n            f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress1
+- type: prompt
+  prompt: "You are AI-Backend (also known as Blake), a backend development specialist\
+    \ who\ndesigns robust APIs, efficient databases, and scalable server architectures.\n\
+    \n## Your Role\n- Design clean, consistent API interfaces\n- Model data relationships\
+    \ and storage strategies\n- Ensure proper authentication and authorization\n-\
+    \ Consider transaction handling and data integrity\n- Apply backend best practices\
+    \ and patterns\n\n## Your Perspective\n- APIs are contracts - design them carefully\n\
+    - Database design determines application limits\n- N+1 queries are the silent\
+    \ performance killer\n- Idempotency matters for reliability\n- Think about the\
+    \ data lifecycle\n\n## Backend Checklist\n- API design (REST/GraphQL conventions)\n\
+    - Database schema and indexes\n- Authentication/Authorization flow\n- Transaction\
+    \ boundaries\n- Caching strategy\n- Error handling and logging\n- Rate limiting\
+    \ and quotas\n- Migration strategy\n\n## Phase Context\n{phase_context}\n\n##\
+    \ Diagrams\nWhen creating API or database diagrams, include a reference marker.\n\
+    Diagram path to use: {diagram_path}\n\nIMPORTANT: When you create a diagram, your\
+    \ comment MUST include:\nDIAGRAM: {diagram_path}\n\n## Current Discussion\n{input}\n\
+    \n## Your Task\n{callout}\n\nFollow the phase instructions. Analyze from a backend\
+    \ development perspective.\n\n## Response Format\nRespond with valid JSON only.\
+    \ Use \\n for newlines in strings:\n{{\n  \"comment\": \"Your backend analysis...\\\
+    n\\nDIAGRAM: path/file.puml (if created)\",\n  \"vote\": \"READY\" or \"CHANGES\"\
+    \ or \"REJECT\" or null,\n  \"diagram\": \"@startuml\\n...\\n@enduml\"\n}}\n\n\
+    Vote meanings:\n- READY: Backend implementation is solid\n- CHANGES: Backend improvements\
+    \ needed\n- REJECT: Significant backend issues\n- null: Comment only, no vote\
+    \ change\n\nIf you have nothing meaningful to add, respond: {{\"sentinel\": \"\
+    NO_RESPONSE\"}}\n"
+  provider: codex
+  output_var: response
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nline = f\"[{timestamp}] [backend] AI response received\"\nprint(line,\
+    \ file=sys.stderr)\nsys.stderr.flush()\nif log_file:\n    with open(log_file,\
+    \ 'a') as f:\n        f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n        f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress2
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\njson_text = response.strip()\nif json_text.startswith('```'):\n\
+    \    code_block = re.search(r'```(?:json)?\\s*(\\{.*\\})\\s*```', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n\
+    \    if code_block:\n        json_text = code_block.group(1).strip()\n"
+  output_var: json_text
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\ntry:\n    parsed = json.loads(json_text)\nexcept json.JSONDecodeError\
+    \ as e:\n    fixed = json_text.replace('\\n', '\\\\n')\n    try:\n        parsed\
+    \ = json.loads(fixed)\n    except json.JSONDecodeError:\n        import re\n \
+    \       comment_match = re.search(r'\"comment\"\\s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])',\
+    \ json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        vote_match = re.search(r'\"vote\"\\s*:\\s*(\"\
+    ?\\w+\"?|null)', json_text)\n        diagram_match = re.search(r'\"diagram\"\\\
+    s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        parsed = {\n   \
+    \         \"comment\": comment_match.group(1).replace('\\n', ' ') if comment_match\
+    \ else \"Parse error\",\n            \"vote\": vote_match.group(1).strip('\"')\
+    \ if vote_match else None,\n            \"diagram\": diagram_match.group(1) if\
+    \ diagram_match else None\n        }\n        if parsed[\"vote\"] == \"null\"\
+    :\n            parsed[\"vote\"] = None\ncomment = parsed.get(\"comment\", \"\"\
+    )\nvote = parsed.get(\"vote\")\ndiagram_content = parsed.get(\"diagram\")\nhas_diagram\
+    \ = \"true\" if diagram_content else \"false\"\n"
+  output_var: comment, vote, diagram_content, has_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "if has_diagram == \"true\" and diagram_content:\n    with open(diagram_path,\
+    \ 'w') as f:\n        f.write(diagram_content)\n    saved_diagram = diagram_path\n\
+    else:\n    saved_diagram = \"\"\n"
+  output_var: saved_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\nresult = {\"comment\": comment, \"vote\": vote}\nif saved_diagram:\n\
+    \    result[\"diagram_file\"] = saved_diagram\nfinal_response = json.dumps(result)\n"
+  output_var: final_response
+output: '{final_response}'

smarttools/discussion-designer/config.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,141 @@
+name: discussion-designer
+description: UI/Visual design specialist participant for discussions
+category: Discussion
+meta:
+  display_name: AI-Designer
+  alias: designer
+  type: voting
+  expertise:
+  - Visual design
+  - UI patterns
+  - Color theory
+  - Typography
+  - Layout systems
+  - Design systems
+  - Accessibility (visual)
+  concerns:
+  - Is the visual hierarchy clear?
+  - Does this follow design system guidelines?
+  - Is the interface aesthetically pleasing and consistent?
+  - Are visual elements accessible (contrast, sizing)?
+  voice: en-GB-Neural2-A
+  provider: claude-haiku
+  color:
+  - 200
+  - 100
+  - 255
+arguments:
+- flag: --callout
+  variable: callout
+  default: ''
+  description: Specific question or @mention context
+- flag: --templates-dir
+  variable: templates_dir
+  default: templates
+  description: Path to templates directory
+- flag: --diagrams-dir
+  variable: diagrams_dir
+  default: diagrams
+  description: Path to save diagrams
+- flag: --log-file
+  variable: log_file
+  default: ''
+  description: Path to log file for progress updates
+steps:
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\nphase_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Phase:\\s*(\\w+)\\\
+    s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\ntemplate_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Template:\\\
+    s*(\\w+)\\s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\n\ncurrent_phase = phase_match.group(1)\
+    \ if phase_match else \"initial_feedback\"\ntemplate_name = template_match.group(1)\
+    \ if template_match else \"feature\"\n\ntemplate_path = os.path.join(templates_dir,\
+    \ template_name + \".yaml\")\nphase_goal = \"Provide design feedback\"\nphase_instructions\
+    \ = \"Review the proposal for visual design concerns.\"\n\nif os.path.exists(template_path):\n\
+    \    import yaml\n    with open(template_path, 'r') as f:\n        template =\
+    \ yaml.safe_load(f)\n    phases = template.get(\"phases\", {})\n    phase_info\
+    \ = phases.get(current_phase, {})\n    phase_goal = phase_info.get(\"goal\", phase_goal)\n\
+    \    phase_instructions = phase_info.get(\"instructions\", phase_instructions)\n\
+    \nphase_context = \"Current Phase: \" + current_phase + \"\\n\"\nphase_context\
+    \ += \"Phase Goal: \" + phase_goal + \"\\n\"\nphase_context += \"Phase Instructions:\\\
+    n\" + phase_instructions\n"
+  output_var: phase_context, current_phase
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\ntitle_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Title:\\s*(.+?)\\\
+    s*-->', input)\ndiscussion_name = \"discussion\"\nif title_match:\n    discussion_name\
+    \ = title_match.group(1).strip().lower()\n    discussion_name = re.sub(r'[^a-z0-9]+',\
+    \ '-', discussion_name)\n\nos.makedirs(diagrams_dir, exist_ok=True)\n\nexisting\
+    \ = []\nif os.path.exists(diagrams_dir):\n    for f in os.listdir(diagrams_dir):\n\
+    \        if f.startswith(discussion_name):\n            existing.append(f)\n\n\
+    next_num = len(existing) + 1\ndiagram_path = diagrams_dir + \"/\" + discussion_name\
+    \ + \"_designer_\" + str(next_num) + \".puml\"\n"
+  output_var: diagram_path
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nfor msg in [f\"Phase: {current_phase}\", \"Calling AI provider...\"\
+    ]:\n    line = f\"[{timestamp}] [designer] {msg}\"\n    print(line, file=sys.stderr)\n\
+    \    sys.stderr.flush()\n    if log_file:\n        with open(log_file, 'a') as\
+    \ f:\n            f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n            f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress1
+- type: prompt
+  prompt: "You are AI-Designer (also known as Dana), a visual design specialist who\
+    \ focuses on\ncreating beautiful, intuitive, and consistent user interfaces.\n\
+    \n## Your Role\n- Evaluate visual design decisions and aesthetics\n- Ensure consistency\
+    \ with design systems and patterns\n- Consider visual hierarchy and information\
+    \ architecture\n- Suggest improvements for clarity and usability\n- Balance aesthetics\
+    \ with functionality\n\n## Your Perspective\n- Design is how it works, not just\
+    \ how it looks\n- Consistency builds trust and reduces cognitive load\n- White\
+    \ space is a design element, not empty space\n- Every visual element should serve\
+    \ a purpose\n- Accessible design is good design\n\n## Design Checklist\n- Visual\
+    \ hierarchy (what draws attention first?)\n- Color usage and contrast ratios\n\
+    - Typography (readability, scale, weight)\n- Spacing and alignment\n- Component\
+    \ consistency\n- Responsive considerations\n- Brand alignment\n\n## Phase Context\n\
+    {phase_context}\n\n## Diagrams\nWhen creating wireframes or layout diagrams, include\
+    \ a reference marker.\nDiagram path to use: {diagram_path}\n\nIMPORTANT: When\
+    \ you create a diagram, your comment MUST include:\nDIAGRAM: {diagram_path}\n\n\
+    ## Current Discussion\n{input}\n\n## Your Task\n{callout}\n\nFollow the phase\
+    \ instructions. Analyze from a visual design perspective.\n\n## Response Format\n\
+    Respond with valid JSON only. Use \\n for newlines in strings:\n{{\n  \"comment\"\
+    : \"Your design analysis...\\n\\nDIAGRAM: path/file.puml (if created)\",\n  \"\
+    vote\": \"READY\" or \"CHANGES\" or \"REJECT\" or null,\n  \"diagram\": \"@startuml\\\
+    n...\\n@enduml\"\n}}\n\nVote meanings:\n- READY: Design is solid and consistent\n\
+    - CHANGES: Design improvements needed\n- REJECT: Fundamental design issues\n-\
+    \ null: Comment only, no vote change\n\nIf you have nothing meaningful to add,\
+    \ respond: {{\"sentinel\": \"NO_RESPONSE\"}}\n"
+  provider: claude-haiku
+  output_var: response
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nline = f\"[{timestamp}] [designer] AI response received\"\nprint(line,\
+    \ file=sys.stderr)\nsys.stderr.flush()\nif log_file:\n    with open(log_file,\
+    \ 'a') as f:\n        f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n        f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress2
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\njson_text = response.strip()\nif json_text.startswith('```'):\n\
+    \    code_block = re.search(r'```(?:json)?\\s*(\\{.*\\})\\s*```', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n\
+    \    if code_block:\n        json_text = code_block.group(1).strip()\n"
+  output_var: json_text
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\ntry:\n    parsed = json.loads(json_text)\nexcept json.JSONDecodeError\
+    \ as e:\n    fixed = json_text.replace('\\n', '\\\\n')\n    try:\n        parsed\
+    \ = json.loads(fixed)\n    except json.JSONDecodeError:\n        import re\n \
+    \       comment_match = re.search(r'\"comment\"\\s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])',\
+    \ json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        vote_match = re.search(r'\"vote\"\\s*:\\s*(\"\
+    ?\\w+\"?|null)', json_text)\n        diagram_match = re.search(r'\"diagram\"\\\
+    s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        parsed = {\n   \
+    \         \"comment\": comment_match.group(1).replace('\\n', ' ') if comment_match\
+    \ else \"Parse error\",\n            \"vote\": vote_match.group(1).strip('\"')\
+    \ if vote_match else None,\n            \"diagram\": diagram_match.group(1) if\
+    \ diagram_match else None\n        }\n        if parsed[\"vote\"] == \"null\"\
+    :\n            parsed[\"vote\"] = None\ncomment = parsed.get(\"comment\", \"\"\
+    )\nvote = parsed.get(\"vote\")\ndiagram_content = parsed.get(\"diagram\")\nhas_diagram\
+    \ = \"true\" if diagram_content else \"false\"\n"
+  output_var: comment, vote, diagram_content, has_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "if has_diagram == \"true\" and diagram_content:\n    with open(diagram_path,\
+    \ 'w') as f:\n        f.write(diagram_content)\n    saved_diagram = diagram_path\n\
+    else:\n    saved_diagram = \"\"\n"
+  output_var: saved_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\nresult = {\"comment\": comment, \"vote\": vote}\nif saved_diagram:\n\
+    \    result[\"diagram_file\"] = saved_diagram\nfinal_response = json.dumps(result)\n"
+  output_var: final_response
+output: '{final_response}'

smarttools/discussion-devops/config.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,143 @@
+name: discussion-devops
+description: DevOps specialist participant for discussions
+category: Discussion
+meta:
+  display_name: AI-DevOps
+  alias: devops
+  type: voting
+  expertise:
+  - CI/CD pipelines
+  - Infrastructure as Code
+  - Container orchestration
+  - Monitoring and observability
+  - Cloud platforms (AWS
+  - GCP
+  - Azure)
+  - Configuration management
+  - Deployment strategies
+  concerns:
+  - How do we deploy this?
+  - What's the monitoring strategy?
+  - Is this infrastructure scalable?
+  - How do we handle rollbacks?
+  voice: en-US-Neural2-F
+  provider: claude
+  color:
+  - 100
+  - 200
+  - 255
+arguments:
+- flag: --callout
+  variable: callout
+  default: ''
+  description: Specific question or @mention context
+- flag: --templates-dir
+  variable: templates_dir
+  default: templates
+  description: Path to templates directory
+- flag: --diagrams-dir
+  variable: diagrams_dir
+  default: diagrams
+  description: Path to save diagrams
+- flag: --log-file
+  variable: log_file
+  default: ''
+  description: Path to log file for progress updates
+steps:
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\nphase_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Phase:\\s*(\\w+)\\\
+    s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\ntemplate_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Template:\\\
+    s*(\\w+)\\s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\n\ncurrent_phase = phase_match.group(1)\
+    \ if phase_match else \"initial_feedback\"\ntemplate_name = template_match.group(1)\
+    \ if template_match else \"feature\"\n\ntemplate_path = os.path.join(templates_dir,\
+    \ template_name + \".yaml\")\nphase_goal = \"Provide DevOps feedback\"\nphase_instructions\
+    \ = \"Review the proposal for deployment and infrastructure concerns.\"\n\nif\
+    \ os.path.exists(template_path):\n    import yaml\n    with open(template_path,\
+    \ 'r') as f:\n        template = yaml.safe_load(f)\n    phases = template.get(\"\
+    phases\", {})\n    phase_info = phases.get(current_phase, {})\n    phase_goal\
+    \ = phase_info.get(\"goal\", phase_goal)\n    phase_instructions = phase_info.get(\"\
+    instructions\", phase_instructions)\n\nphase_context = \"Current Phase: \" + current_phase\
+    \ + \"\\n\"\nphase_context += \"Phase Goal: \" + phase_goal + \"\\n\"\nphase_context\
+    \ += \"Phase Instructions:\\n\" + phase_instructions\n"
+  output_var: phase_context, current_phase
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\ntitle_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Title:\\s*(.+?)\\\
+    s*-->', input)\ndiscussion_name = \"discussion\"\nif title_match:\n    discussion_name\
+    \ = title_match.group(1).strip().lower()\n    discussion_name = re.sub(r'[^a-z0-9]+',\
+    \ '-', discussion_name)\n\nos.makedirs(diagrams_dir, exist_ok=True)\n\nexisting\
+    \ = []\nif os.path.exists(diagrams_dir):\n    for f in os.listdir(diagrams_dir):\n\
+    \        if f.startswith(discussion_name):\n            existing.append(f)\n\n\
+    next_num = len(existing) + 1\ndiagram_path = diagrams_dir + \"/\" + discussion_name\
+    \ + \"_devops_\" + str(next_num) + \".puml\"\n"
+  output_var: diagram_path
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nfor msg in [f\"Phase: {current_phase}\", \"Calling AI provider...\"\
+    ]:\n    line = f\"[{timestamp}] [devops] {msg}\"\n    print(line, file=sys.stderr)\n\
+    \    sys.stderr.flush()\n    if log_file:\n        with open(log_file, 'a') as\
+    \ f:\n            f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n            f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress1
+- type: prompt
+  prompt: "You are AI-DevOps (also known as Devon), a DevOps specialist who ensures\n\
+    reliable deployments, robust infrastructure, and comprehensive observability.\n\
+    \n## Your Role\n- Design deployment pipelines and strategies\n- Plan infrastructure\
+    \ and scaling approaches\n- Ensure monitoring and alerting coverage\n- Consider\
+    \ disaster recovery and rollback procedures\n- Apply DevOps and SRE best practices\n\
+    \n## Your Perspective\n- If it's not automated, it's a future incident\n- Monitoring\
+    \ is not optional - you can't fix what you can't see\n- Every deployment should\
+    \ be reversible\n- Infrastructure as code prevents configuration drift\n- Chaos\
+    \ is inevitable - plan for it\n\n## DevOps Checklist\n- CI/CD pipeline requirements\n\
+    - Container/orchestration needs\n- Environment configuration\n- Secrets management\n\
+    - Monitoring and alerting\n- Logging and tracing\n- Backup and recovery\n- Scaling\
+    \ strategy (horizontal/vertical)\n- Deployment strategy (blue-green, canary, rolling)\n\
+    \n## Phase Context\n{phase_context}\n\n## Diagrams\nWhen creating infrastructure\
+    \ or deployment diagrams, include a reference marker.\nDiagram path to use: {diagram_path}\n\
+    \nIMPORTANT: When you create a diagram, your comment MUST include:\nDIAGRAM: {diagram_path}\n\
+    \n## Current Discussion\n{input}\n\n## Your Task\n{callout}\n\nFollow the phase\
+    \ instructions. Analyze from a DevOps/infrastructure perspective.\n\n## Response\
+    \ Format\nRespond with valid JSON only. Use \\n for newlines in strings:\n{{\n\
+    \  \"comment\": \"Your DevOps analysis...\\n\\nDIAGRAM: path/file.puml (if created)\"\
+    ,\n  \"vote\": \"READY\" or \"CHANGES\" or \"REJECT\" or null,\n  \"diagram\"\
+    : \"@startuml\\n...\\n@enduml\"\n}}\n\nVote meanings:\n- READY: Deployment/infrastructure\
+    \ is solid\n- CHANGES: DevOps improvements needed\n- REJECT: Significant infrastructure\
+    \ issues\n- null: Comment only, no vote change\n\nIf you have nothing meaningful\
+    \ to add, respond: {{\"sentinel\": \"NO_RESPONSE\"}}\n"
+  provider: claude
+  output_var: response
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nline = f\"[{timestamp}] [devops] AI response received\"\nprint(line,\
+    \ file=sys.stderr)\nsys.stderr.flush()\nif log_file:\n    with open(log_file,\
+    \ 'a') as f:\n        f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n        f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress2
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\njson_text = response.strip()\nif json_text.startswith('```'):\n\
+    \    code_block = re.search(r'```(?:json)?\\s*(\\{.*\\})\\s*```', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n\
+    \    if code_block:\n        json_text = code_block.group(1).strip()\n"
+  output_var: json_text
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\ntry:\n    parsed = json.loads(json_text)\nexcept json.JSONDecodeError\
+    \ as e:\n    fixed = json_text.replace('\\n', '\\\\n')\n    try:\n        parsed\
+    \ = json.loads(fixed)\n    except json.JSONDecodeError:\n        import re\n \
+    \       comment_match = re.search(r'\"comment\"\\s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])',\
+    \ json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        vote_match = re.search(r'\"vote\"\\s*:\\s*(\"\
+    ?\\w+\"?|null)', json_text)\n        diagram_match = re.search(r'\"diagram\"\\\
+    s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        parsed = {\n   \
+    \         \"comment\": comment_match.group(1).replace('\\n', ' ') if comment_match\
+    \ else \"Parse error\",\n            \"vote\": vote_match.group(1).strip('\"')\
+    \ if vote_match else None,\n            \"diagram\": diagram_match.group(1) if\
+    \ diagram_match else None\n        }\n        if parsed[\"vote\"] == \"null\"\
+    :\n            parsed[\"vote\"] = None\ncomment = parsed.get(\"comment\", \"\"\
+    )\nvote = parsed.get(\"vote\")\ndiagram_content = parsed.get(\"diagram\")\nhas_diagram\
+    \ = \"true\" if diagram_content else \"false\"\n"
+  output_var: comment, vote, diagram_content, has_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "if has_diagram == \"true\" and diagram_content:\n    with open(diagram_path,\
+    \ 'w') as f:\n        f.write(diagram_content)\n    saved_diagram = diagram_path\n\
+    else:\n    saved_diagram = \"\"\n"
+  output_var: saved_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\nresult = {\"comment\": comment, \"vote\": vote}\nif saved_diagram:\n\
+    \    result[\"diagram_file\"] = saved_diagram\nfinal_response = json.dumps(result)\n"
+  output_var: final_response
+output: '{final_response}'

smarttools/discussion-frontend/config.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,141 @@
+name: discussion-frontend
+description: Frontend development specialist participant for discussions
+category: Discussion
+meta:
+  display_name: AI-Frontend
+  alias: frontend
+  type: voting
+  expertise:
+  - React/Vue/Angular
+  - CSS/Styling
+  - Component architecture
+  - State management
+  - Browser APIs
+  - Performance optimization
+  - Responsive design
+  concerns:
+  - Is this component reusable?
+  - What's the state management strategy?
+  - How does this affect bundle size?
+  - Is this accessible and responsive?
+  voice: en-US-Neural2-C
+  provider: opencode-pickle
+  color:
+  - 255
+  - 150
+  - 200
+arguments:
+- flag: --callout
+  variable: callout
+  default: ''
+  description: Specific question or @mention context
+- flag: --templates-dir
+  variable: templates_dir
+  default: templates
+  description: Path to templates directory
+- flag: --diagrams-dir
+  variable: diagrams_dir
+  default: diagrams
+  description: Path to save diagrams
+- flag: --log-file
+  variable: log_file
+  default: ''
+  description: Path to log file for progress updates
+steps:
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\nphase_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Phase:\\s*(\\w+)\\\
+    s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\ntemplate_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Template:\\\
+    s*(\\w+)\\s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\n\ncurrent_phase = phase_match.group(1)\
+    \ if phase_match else \"initial_feedback\"\ntemplate_name = template_match.group(1)\
+    \ if template_match else \"feature\"\n\ntemplate_path = os.path.join(templates_dir,\
+    \ template_name + \".yaml\")\nphase_goal = \"Provide frontend feedback\"\nphase_instructions\
+    \ = \"Review the proposal for frontend implementation concerns.\"\n\nif os.path.exists(template_path):\n\
+    \    import yaml\n    with open(template_path, 'r') as f:\n        template =\
+    \ yaml.safe_load(f)\n    phases = template.get(\"phases\", {})\n    phase_info\
+    \ = phases.get(current_phase, {})\n    phase_goal = phase_info.get(\"goal\", phase_goal)\n\
+    \    phase_instructions = phase_info.get(\"instructions\", phase_instructions)\n\
+    \nphase_context = \"Current Phase: \" + current_phase + \"\\n\"\nphase_context\
+    \ += \"Phase Goal: \" + phase_goal + \"\\n\"\nphase_context += \"Phase Instructions:\\\
+    n\" + phase_instructions\n"
+  output_var: phase_context, current_phase
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\ntitle_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Title:\\s*(.+?)\\\
+    s*-->', input)\ndiscussion_name = \"discussion\"\nif title_match:\n    discussion_name\
+    \ = title_match.group(1).strip().lower()\n    discussion_name = re.sub(r'[^a-z0-9]+',\
+    \ '-', discussion_name)\n\nos.makedirs(diagrams_dir, exist_ok=True)\n\nexisting\
+    \ = []\nif os.path.exists(diagrams_dir):\n    for f in os.listdir(diagrams_dir):\n\
+    \        if f.startswith(discussion_name):\n            existing.append(f)\n\n\
+    next_num = len(existing) + 1\ndiagram_path = diagrams_dir + \"/\" + discussion_name\
+    \ + \"_frontend_\" + str(next_num) + \".puml\"\n"
+  output_var: diagram_path
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nfor msg in [f\"Phase: {current_phase}\", \"Calling AI provider...\"\
+    ]:\n    line = f\"[{timestamp}] [frontend] {msg}\"\n    print(line, file=sys.stderr)\n\
+    \    sys.stderr.flush()\n    if log_file:\n        with open(log_file, 'a') as\
+    \ f:\n            f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n            f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress1
+- type: prompt
+  prompt: "You are AI-Frontend (also known as Fiona), a frontend development specialist\
+    \ who\nbuilds performant, accessible, and maintainable user interfaces.\n\n##\
+    \ Your Role\n- Evaluate frontend architecture and component design\n- Consider\
+    \ state management and data flow\n- Ensure responsive and accessible implementations\n\
+    - Optimize for performance and bundle size\n- Apply modern frontend best practices\n\
+    \n## Your Perspective\n- Components should be composable and reusable\n- Performance\
+    \ matters - every millisecond counts\n- CSS is code - it needs architecture too\n\
+    - Progressive enhancement over graceful degradation\n- Don't fight the browser\
+    \ - work with it\n\n## Frontend Checklist\n- Component hierarchy and data flow\n\
+    - State management approach\n- CSS strategy (modules, styled-components, etc.)\n\
+    - Bundle size impact\n- Browser compatibility\n- Mobile/responsive behavior\n\
+    - Loading and error states\n- Accessibility (keyboard, screen readers)\n\n## Phase\
+    \ Context\n{phase_context}\n\n## Diagrams\nWhen creating component diagrams, include\
+    \ a reference marker.\nDiagram path to use: {diagram_path}\n\nIMPORTANT: When\
+    \ you create a diagram, your comment MUST include:\nDIAGRAM: {diagram_path}\n\n\
+    ## Current Discussion\n{input}\n\n## Your Task\n{callout}\n\nFollow the phase\
+    \ instructions. Analyze from a frontend development perspective.\n\n## Response\
+    \ Format\nRespond with valid JSON only. Use \\n for newlines in strings:\n{{\n\
+    \  \"comment\": \"Your frontend analysis...\\n\\nDIAGRAM: path/file.puml (if created)\"\
+    ,\n  \"vote\": \"READY\" or \"CHANGES\" or \"REJECT\" or null,\n  \"diagram\"\
+    : \"@startuml\\n...\\n@enduml\"\n}}\n\nVote meanings:\n- READY: Frontend implementation\
+    \ is solid\n- CHANGES: Frontend improvements needed\n- REJECT: Significant frontend\
+    \ issues\n- null: Comment only, no vote change\n\nIf you have nothing meaningful\
+    \ to add, respond: {{\"sentinel\": \"NO_RESPONSE\"}}\n"
+  provider: opencode-pickle
+  output_var: response
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nline = f\"[{timestamp}] [frontend] AI response received\"\nprint(line,\
+    \ file=sys.stderr)\nsys.stderr.flush()\nif log_file:\n    with open(log_file,\
+    \ 'a') as f:\n        f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n        f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress2
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\njson_text = response.strip()\nif json_text.startswith('```'):\n\
+    \    code_block = re.search(r'```(?:json)?\\s*(\\{.*\\})\\s*```', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n\
+    \    if code_block:\n        json_text = code_block.group(1).strip()\n"
+  output_var: json_text
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\ntry:\n    parsed = json.loads(json_text)\nexcept json.JSONDecodeError\
+    \ as e:\n    fixed = json_text.replace('\\n', '\\\\n')\n    try:\n        parsed\
+    \ = json.loads(fixed)\n    except json.JSONDecodeError:\n        import re\n \
+    \       comment_match = re.search(r'\"comment\"\\s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])',\
+    \ json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        vote_match = re.search(r'\"vote\"\\s*:\\s*(\"\
+    ?\\w+\"?|null)', json_text)\n        diagram_match = re.search(r'\"diagram\"\\\
+    s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        parsed = {\n   \
+    \         \"comment\": comment_match.group(1).replace('\\n', ' ') if comment_match\
+    \ else \"Parse error\",\n            \"vote\": vote_match.group(1).strip('\"')\
+    \ if vote_match else None,\n            \"diagram\": diagram_match.group(1) if\
+    \ diagram_match else None\n        }\n        if parsed[\"vote\"] == \"null\"\
+    :\n            parsed[\"vote\"] = None\ncomment = parsed.get(\"comment\", \"\"\
+    )\nvote = parsed.get(\"vote\")\ndiagram_content = parsed.get(\"diagram\")\nhas_diagram\
+    \ = \"true\" if diagram_content else \"false\"\n"
+  output_var: comment, vote, diagram_content, has_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "if has_diagram == \"true\" and diagram_content:\n    with open(diagram_path,\
+    \ 'w') as f:\n        f.write(diagram_content)\n    saved_diagram = diagram_path\n\
+    else:\n    saved_diagram = \"\"\n"
+  output_var: saved_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\nresult = {\"comment\": comment, \"vote\": vote}\nif saved_diagram:\n\
+    \    result[\"diagram_file\"] = saved_diagram\nfinal_response = json.dumps(result)\n"
+  output_var: final_response
+output: '{final_response}'

smarttools/discussion-performance/config.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,126 @@
+name: discussion-performance
+description: Performance optimization specialist participant for discussions
+category: Discussion
+meta:
+  display_name: AI-Performance
+  alias: performance
+  type: voting
+  expertise:
+  - Performance profiling
+  - Algorithm optimization
+  - Caching strategies
+  - Database optimization
+  - Memory management
+  - Load testing
+  - Scalability patterns
+  concerns:
+  - What's the time complexity?
+  - Where are the bottlenecks?
+  - How does this scale under load?
+  - Are we using resources efficiently?
+  voice: en-US-Neural2-J
+  provider: opencode-reasoner
+  color:
+  - 255
+  - 220
+  - 100
+arguments:
+- flag: --callout
+  variable: callout
+  default: ''
+  description: Specific question or @mention context
+- flag: --templates-dir
+  variable: templates_dir
+  default: templates
+  description: Path to templates directory
+- flag: --diagrams-dir
+  variable: diagrams_dir
+  default: diagrams
+  description: Path to save diagrams
+- flag: --log-file
+  variable: log_file
+  default: ''
+  description: Path to log file for progress updates
+steps:
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\nphase_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Phase:\\s*(\\w+)\\\
+    s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\ntemplate_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Template:\\\
+    s*(\\w+)\\s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\n\ncurrent_phase = phase_match.group(1)\
+    \ if phase_match else \"initial_feedback\"\ntemplate_name = template_match.group(1)\
+    \ if template_match else \"feature\"\n\ntemplate_path = os.path.join(templates_dir,\
+    \ template_name + \".yaml\")\nphase_goal = \"Provide performance feedback\"\n\
+    phase_instructions = \"Review the proposal for performance and scalability concerns.\"\
+    \n\nif os.path.exists(template_path):\n    import yaml\n    with open(template_path,\
+    \ 'r') as f:\n        template = yaml.safe_load(f)\n    phases = template.get(\"\
+    phases\", {})\n    phase_info = phases.get(current_phase, {})\n    phase_goal\
+    \ = phase_info.get(\"goal\", phase_goal)\n    phase_instructions = phase_info.get(\"\
+    instructions\", phase_instructions)\n\nphase_context = \"Current Phase: \" + current_phase\
+    \ + \"\\n\"\nphase_context += \"Phase Goal: \" + phase_goal + \"\\n\"\nphase_context\
+    \ += \"Phase Instructions:\\n\" + phase_instructions\n"
+  output_var: phase_context, current_phase
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nfor msg in [f\"Phase: {current_phase}\", \"Calling AI provider...\"\
+    ]:\n    line = f\"[{timestamp}] [performance] {msg}\"\n    print(line, file=sys.stderr)\n\
+    \    sys.stderr.flush()\n    if log_file:\n        with open(log_file, 'a') as\
+    \ f:\n            f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n            f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress1
+- type: prompt
+  prompt: "You are AI-Performance (also known as Perry), a performance optimization\
+    \ specialist\nwho ensures systems are fast, efficient, and scalable.\n\n## Your\
+    \ Role\n- Identify potential performance bottlenecks\n- Evaluate algorithmic efficiency\
+    \ and complexity\n- Recommend caching and optimization strategies\n- Consider\
+    \ resource utilization and cost\n- Plan for scale and load testing\n\n## Your\
+    \ Perspective\n- Premature optimization is the root of all evil, but known bottlenecks\
+    \ must be addressed\n- Measure first, optimize second\n- O(n) vs O(n^2) matters\
+    \ more at scale\n- Memory and CPU have different optimization strategies\n- The\
+    \ fastest code is code that doesn't run\n\n## Performance Checklist\n- Time complexity\
+    \ of algorithms\n- Space complexity and memory usage\n- Database query efficiency\
+    \ (indexes, joins)\n- Network round trips\n- Caching opportunities\n- Batch vs\
+    \ real-time processing\n- Concurrency and parallelization\n- Resource pooling\
+    \ and reuse\n\n## Phase Context\n{phase_context}\n\n## Current Discussion\n{input}\n\
+    \n## Your Task\n{callout}\n\nFollow the phase instructions. Analyze from a performance\
+    \ and scalability perspective.\nIdentify bottlenecks, suggest optimizations, and\
+    \ consider scaling implications.\n\n## Response Format\nRespond with valid JSON\
+    \ only. Use \\n for newlines in strings:\n{{\n  \"comment\": \"Your performance\
+    \ analysis...\\n\\nOptimization opportunities:\\n1. ...\\n2. ...\",\n  \"vote\"\
+    : \"READY\" or \"CHANGES\" or \"REJECT\" or null,\n  \"diagram\": null\n}}\n\n\
+    Vote meanings:\n- READY: Performance is acceptable\n- CHANGES: Performance improvements\
+    \ needed\n- REJECT: Significant performance issues\n- null: Comment only, no vote\
+    \ change\n\nIf you have nothing meaningful to add, respond: {{\"sentinel\": \"\
+    NO_RESPONSE\"}}\n"
+  provider: opencode-reasoner
+  output_var: response
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nline = f\"[{timestamp}] [performance] AI response received\"\nprint(line,\
+    \ file=sys.stderr)\nsys.stderr.flush()\nif log_file:\n    with open(log_file,\
+    \ 'a') as f:\n        f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n        f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress2
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\njson_text = response.strip()\nif json_text.startswith('```'):\n\
+    \    code_block = re.search(r'```(?:json)?\\s*(\\{.*\\})\\s*```', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n\
+    \    if code_block:\n        json_text = code_block.group(1).strip()\n"
+  output_var: json_text
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\ntry:\n    parsed = json.loads(json_text)\nexcept json.JSONDecodeError\
+    \ as e:\n    fixed = json_text.replace('\\n', '\\\\n')\n    try:\n        parsed\
+    \ = json.loads(fixed)\n    except json.JSONDecodeError:\n        import re\n \
+    \       comment_match = re.search(r'\"comment\"\\s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])',\
+    \ json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        vote_match = re.search(r'\"vote\"\\s*:\\s*(\"\
+    ?\\w+\"?|null)', json_text)\n        parsed = {\n            \"comment\": comment_match.group(1).replace('\\\
+    n', ' ') if comment_match else \"Parse error\",\n            \"vote\": vote_match.group(1).strip('\"\
+    ') if vote_match else None\n        }\n        if parsed[\"vote\"] == \"null\"\
+    :\n            parsed[\"vote\"] = None\ncomment = parsed.get(\"comment\", \"\"\
+    )\nvote = parsed.get(\"vote\")\n"
+  output_var: comment, vote
+- type: code
+  code: 'import json
+
+    result = {"comment": comment, "vote": vote}
+
+    final_response = json.dumps(result)
+
+    '
+  output_var: final_response
+output: '{final_response}'

smarttools/discussion-qa/config.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,135 @@
+name: discussion-qa
+description: Quality assurance specialist participant for discussions
+category: Discussion
+meta:
+  display_name: AI-QA
+  alias: qa
+  type: voting
+  expertise:
+  - Test strategy
+  - Edge case identification
+  - Regression testing
+  - Error handling
+  - Quality metrics
+  - Bug prevention
+  - Test automation
+  concerns:
+  - What could go wrong?
+  - How do we test this?
+  - What are the edge cases?
+  - Is error handling sufficient?
+  voice: en-US-Neural2-D
+  provider: gemini
+  color:
+  - 180
+  - 255
+  - 100
+arguments:
+- flag: --callout
+  variable: callout
+  default: ''
+  description: Specific question or @mention context
+- flag: --templates-dir
+  variable: templates_dir
+  default: templates
+  description: Path to templates directory
+- flag: --diagrams-dir
+  variable: diagrams_dir
+  default: diagrams
+  description: Path to save diagrams
+- flag: --log-file
+  variable: log_file
+  default: ''
+  description: Path to log file for progress updates
+steps:
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\nphase_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Phase:\\s*(\\w+)\\\
+    s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\ntemplate_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Template:\\\
+    s*(\\w+)\\s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\n\ncurrent_phase = phase_match.group(1)\
+    \ if phase_match else \"initial_feedback\"\ntemplate_name = template_match.group(1)\
+    \ if template_match else \"feature\"\n\ntemplate_path = os.path.join(templates_dir,\
+    \ template_name + \".yaml\")\nphase_goal = \"Provide QA feedback\"\nphase_instructions\
+    \ = \"Review the proposal for testability and quality concerns.\"\n\nif os.path.exists(template_path):\n\
+    \    import yaml\n    with open(template_path, 'r') as f:\n        template =\
+    \ yaml.safe_load(f)\n    phases = template.get(\"phases\", {})\n    phase_info\
+    \ = phases.get(current_phase, {})\n    phase_goal = phase_info.get(\"goal\", phase_goal)\n\
+    \    phase_instructions = phase_info.get(\"instructions\", phase_instructions)\n\
+    \nphase_context = \"Current Phase: \" + current_phase + \"\\n\"\nphase_context\
+    \ += \"Phase Goal: \" + phase_goal + \"\\n\"\nphase_context += \"Phase Instructions:\\\
+    n\" + phase_instructions\n"
+  output_var: phase_context, current_phase
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\ntitle_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Title:\\s*(.+?)\\\
+    s*-->', input)\ndiscussion_name = \"discussion\"\nif title_match:\n    discussion_name\
+    \ = title_match.group(1).strip().lower()\n    discussion_name = re.sub(r'[^a-z0-9]+',\
+    \ '-', discussion_name)\n\nos.makedirs(diagrams_dir, exist_ok=True)\n\nexisting\
+    \ = []\nif os.path.exists(diagrams_dir):\n    for f in os.listdir(diagrams_dir):\n\
+    \        if f.startswith(discussion_name):\n            existing.append(f)\n\n\
+    next_num = len(existing) + 1\ndiagram_path = diagrams_dir + \"/\" + discussion_name\
+    \ + \"_qa_\" + str(next_num) + \".puml\"\n"
+  output_var: diagram_path
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nfor msg in [f\"Phase: {current_phase}\", \"Calling AI provider...\"\
+    ]:\n    line = f\"[{timestamp}] [qa] {msg}\"\n    print(line, file=sys.stderr)\n\
+    \    sys.stderr.flush()\n    if log_file:\n        with open(log_file, 'a') as\
+    \ f:\n            f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n            f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress1
+- type: prompt
+  prompt: "You are AI-QA (also known as Quinn), a quality assurance specialist who\
+    \ ensures\nsoftware is reliable, well-tested, and handles edge cases gracefully.\n\
+    \n## Your Role\n- Identify potential bugs and edge cases before they happen\n\
+    - Design comprehensive test strategies\n- Evaluate error handling and failure\
+    \ modes\n- Ensure testability of proposed implementations\n- Think about what\
+    \ could go wrong\n\n## Your Perspective\n- If it can break, it will break - in\
+    \ production, at 3 AM\n- Edge cases are where most bugs hide\n- Good error messages\
+    \ save hours of debugging\n- Tests are documentation that never goes stale\n-\
+    \ Prevention is cheaper than debugging\n\n## QA Checklist\n- Happy path testing\n\
+    - Error/exception handling\n- Boundary conditions (empty, null, max values)\n\
+    - Concurrency and race conditions\n- Integration points and failure modes\n- Rollback\
+    \ and recovery scenarios\n- Data validation and sanitization\n- Performance under\
+    \ load\n\n## Phase Context\n{phase_context}\n\n## Current Discussion\n{input}\n\
+    \n## Your Task\n{callout}\n\nFollow the phase instructions. Analyze from a quality\
+    \ assurance perspective.\nIdentify edge cases, failure modes, and testing requirements.\n\
+    \n## Response Format\nRespond with valid JSON only. Use \\n for newlines in strings:\n\
+    {{\n  \"comment\": \"Your QA analysis...\\n\\nTest cases:\\n1. ...\\n2. ...\"\
+    ,\n  \"vote\": \"READY\" or \"CHANGES\" or \"REJECT\" or null,\n  \"diagram\"\
+    : null\n}}\n\nVote meanings:\n- READY: Quality is assured, testable\n- CHANGES:\
+    \ Testing/quality improvements needed\n- REJECT: Untestable or high-risk implementation\n\
+    - null: Comment only, no vote change\n\nIf you have nothing meaningful to add,\
+    \ respond: {{\"sentinel\": \"NO_RESPONSE\"}}\n"
+  provider: gemini
+  output_var: response
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nline = f\"[{timestamp}] [qa] AI response received\"\nprint(line,\
+    \ file=sys.stderr)\nsys.stderr.flush()\nif log_file:\n    with open(log_file,\
+    \ 'a') as f:\n        f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n        f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress2
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\njson_text = response.strip()\nif json_text.startswith('```'):\n\
+    \    code_block = re.search(r'```(?:json)?\\s*(\\{.*\\})\\s*```', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n\
+    \    if code_block:\n        json_text = code_block.group(1).strip()\n"
+  output_var: json_text
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\ntry:\n    parsed = json.loads(json_text)\nexcept json.JSONDecodeError\
+    \ as e:\n    fixed = json_text.replace('\\n', '\\\\n')\n    try:\n        parsed\
+    \ = json.loads(fixed)\n    except json.JSONDecodeError:\n        import re\n \
+    \       comment_match = re.search(r'\"comment\"\\s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])',\
+    \ json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        vote_match = re.search(r'\"vote\"\\s*:\\s*(\"\
+    ?\\w+\"?|null)', json_text)\n        parsed = {\n            \"comment\": comment_match.group(1).replace('\\\
+    n', ' ') if comment_match else \"Parse error\",\n            \"vote\": vote_match.group(1).strip('\"\
+    ') if vote_match else None\n        }\n        if parsed[\"vote\"] == \"null\"\
+    :\n            parsed[\"vote\"] = None\ncomment = parsed.get(\"comment\", \"\"\
+    )\nvote = parsed.get(\"vote\")\n"
+  output_var: comment, vote
+- type: code
+  code: 'import json
+
+    result = {"comment": comment, "vote": vote}
+
+    final_response = json.dumps(result)
+
+    '
+  output_var: final_response
+output: '{final_response}'

smarttools/discussion-ux/config.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,141 @@
+name: discussion-ux
+description: User experience specialist participant for discussions
+category: Discussion
+meta:
+  display_name: AI-UX
+  alias: ux
+  type: voting
+  expertise:
+  - User research
+  - Usability testing
+  - User flows
+  - Information architecture
+  - Accessibility (WCAG)
+  - Interaction design
+  - User journey mapping
+  concerns:
+  - Is this intuitive for users?
+  - What's the cognitive load?
+  - Are we meeting accessibility standards?
+  - What user problems are we solving?
+  voice: en-AU-Neural2-A
+  provider: gemini-flash
+  color:
+  - 100
+  - 220
+  - 200
+arguments:
+- flag: --callout
+  variable: callout
+  default: ''
+  description: Specific question or @mention context
+- flag: --templates-dir
+  variable: templates_dir
+  default: templates
+  description: Path to templates directory
+- flag: --diagrams-dir
+  variable: diagrams_dir
+  default: diagrams
+  description: Path to save diagrams
+- flag: --log-file
+  variable: log_file
+  default: ''
+  description: Path to log file for progress updates
+steps:
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\nphase_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Phase:\\s*(\\w+)\\\
+    s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\ntemplate_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Template:\\\
+    s*(\\w+)\\s*-->', input, re.IGNORECASE)\n\ncurrent_phase = phase_match.group(1)\
+    \ if phase_match else \"initial_feedback\"\ntemplate_name = template_match.group(1)\
+    \ if template_match else \"feature\"\n\ntemplate_path = os.path.join(templates_dir,\
+    \ template_name + \".yaml\")\nphase_goal = \"Provide UX feedback\"\nphase_instructions\
+    \ = \"Review the proposal for user experience concerns.\"\n\nif os.path.exists(template_path):\n\
+    \    import yaml\n    with open(template_path, 'r') as f:\n        template =\
+    \ yaml.safe_load(f)\n    phases = template.get(\"phases\", {})\n    phase_info\
+    \ = phases.get(current_phase, {})\n    phase_goal = phase_info.get(\"goal\", phase_goal)\n\
+    \    phase_instructions = phase_info.get(\"instructions\", phase_instructions)\n\
+    \nphase_context = \"Current Phase: \" + current_phase + \"\\n\"\nphase_context\
+    \ += \"Phase Goal: \" + phase_goal + \"\\n\"\nphase_context += \"Phase Instructions:\\\
+    n\" + phase_instructions\n"
+  output_var: phase_context, current_phase
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\nimport os\n\ntitle_match = re.search(r'<!--\\s*Title:\\s*(.+?)\\\
+    s*-->', input)\ndiscussion_name = \"discussion\"\nif title_match:\n    discussion_name\
+    \ = title_match.group(1).strip().lower()\n    discussion_name = re.sub(r'[^a-z0-9]+',\
+    \ '-', discussion_name)\n\nos.makedirs(diagrams_dir, exist_ok=True)\n\nexisting\
+    \ = []\nif os.path.exists(diagrams_dir):\n    for f in os.listdir(diagrams_dir):\n\
+    \        if f.startswith(discussion_name):\n            existing.append(f)\n\n\
+    next_num = len(existing) + 1\ndiagram_path = diagrams_dir + \"/\" + discussion_name\
+    \ + \"_ux_\" + str(next_num) + \".puml\"\n"
+  output_var: diagram_path
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nfor msg in [f\"Phase: {current_phase}\", \"Calling AI provider...\"\
+    ]:\n    line = f\"[{timestamp}] [ux] {msg}\"\n    print(line, file=sys.stderr)\n\
+    \    sys.stderr.flush()\n    if log_file:\n        with open(log_file, 'a') as\
+    \ f:\n            f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n            f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress1
+- type: prompt
+  prompt: "You are AI-UX (also known as Uma), a user experience specialist who advocates\n\
+    for users and ensures products are intuitive, accessible, and delightful to use.\n\
+    \n## Your Role\n- Champion the user's perspective in all decisions\n- Evaluate\
+    \ usability and intuitiveness of proposals\n- Ensure accessibility compliance\
+    \ (WCAG 2.1)\n- Design user flows that minimize friction\n- Consider edge cases\
+    \ from the user's viewpoint\n\n## Your Perspective\n- Users don't read manuals\
+    \ - make it obvious\n- Every click/tap is a decision point that can lose users\n\
+    - Error states are part of the experience\n- Accessibility is not optional\n-\
+    \ Test assumptions with real user behavior\n\n## UX Checklist\n- User flow clarity\
+    \ (can users complete their goals?)\n- Error handling and recovery\n- Loading\
+    \ states and feedback\n- Keyboard navigation\n- Screen reader compatibility\n\
+    - Mobile/touch considerations\n- Onboarding and discoverability\n- Cognitive load\
+    \ assessment\n\n## Phase Context\n{phase_context}\n\n## Diagrams\nWhen creating\
+    \ user flow diagrams, include a reference marker.\nDiagram path to use: {diagram_path}\n\
+    \nIMPORTANT: When you create a diagram, your comment MUST include:\nDIAGRAM: {diagram_path}\n\
+    \n## Current Discussion\n{input}\n\n## Your Task\n{callout}\n\nFollow the phase\
+    \ instructions. Analyze from a user experience perspective.\n\n## Response Format\n\
+    Respond with valid JSON only. Use \\n for newlines in strings:\n{{\n  \"comment\"\
+    : \"Your UX analysis...\\n\\nDIAGRAM: path/file.puml (if created)\",\n  \"vote\"\
+    : \"READY\" or \"CHANGES\" or \"REJECT\" or null,\n  \"diagram\": \"@startuml\\\
+    n...\\n@enduml\"\n}}\n\nVote meanings:\n- READY: Good user experience, accessible\n\
+    - CHANGES: UX improvements needed\n- REJECT: Significant usability issues\n- null:\
+    \ Comment only, no vote change\n\nIf you have nothing meaningful to add, respond:\
+    \ {{\"sentinel\": \"NO_RESPONSE\"}}\n"
+  provider: gemini-flash
+  output_var: response
+- type: code
+  code: "import sys\nimport datetime as dt\ntimestamp = dt.datetime.now().strftime(\"\
+    %H:%M:%S\")\nline = f\"[{timestamp}] [ux] AI response received\"\nprint(line,\
+    \ file=sys.stderr)\nsys.stderr.flush()\nif log_file:\n    with open(log_file,\
+    \ 'a') as f:\n        f.write(line + \"\\n\")\n        f.flush()\n"
+  output_var: _progress2
+- type: code
+  code: "import re\njson_text = response.strip()\nif json_text.startswith('```'):\n\
+    \    code_block = re.search(r'```(?:json)?\\s*(\\{.*\\})\\s*```', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n\
+    \    if code_block:\n        json_text = code_block.group(1).strip()\n"
+  output_var: json_text
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\ntry:\n    parsed = json.loads(json_text)\nexcept json.JSONDecodeError\
+    \ as e:\n    fixed = json_text.replace('\\n', '\\\\n')\n    try:\n        parsed\
+    \ = json.loads(fixed)\n    except json.JSONDecodeError:\n        import re\n \
+    \       comment_match = re.search(r'\"comment\"\\s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])',\
+    \ json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        vote_match = re.search(r'\"vote\"\\s*:\\s*(\"\
+    ?\\w+\"?|null)', json_text)\n        diagram_match = re.search(r'\"diagram\"\\\
+    s*:\\s*\"(.*?)\"(?=\\s*[,}])', json_text, re.DOTALL)\n        parsed = {\n   \
+    \         \"comment\": comment_match.group(1).replace('\\n', ' ') if comment_match\
+    \ else \"Parse error\",\n            \"vote\": vote_match.group(1).strip('\"')\
+    \ if vote_match else None,\n            \"diagram\": diagram_match.group(1) if\
+    \ diagram_match else None\n        }\n        if parsed[\"vote\"] == \"null\"\
+    :\n            parsed[\"vote\"] = None\ncomment = parsed.get(\"comment\", \"\"\
+    )\nvote = parsed.get(\"vote\")\ndiagram_content = parsed.get(\"diagram\")\nhas_diagram\
+    \ = \"true\" if diagram_content else \"false\"\n"
+  output_var: comment, vote, diagram_content, has_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "if has_diagram == \"true\" and diagram_content:\n    with open(diagram_path,\
+    \ 'w') as f:\n        f.write(diagram_content)\n    saved_diagram = diagram_path\n\
+    else:\n    saved_diagram = \"\"\n"
+  output_var: saved_diagram
+- type: code
+  code: "import json\nresult = {\"comment\": comment, \"vote\": vote}\nif saved_diagram:\n\
+    \    result[\"diagram_file\"] = saved_diagram\nfinal_response = json.dumps(result)\n"
+  output_var: final_response
+output: '{final_response}'